True Detective: A Comparison of Seasons

By Alexandra Mitchell on Sep 17, 2015 to True Detective



Knowing the second season of True Detective would soon air, I crunched time to be able to watch the first season before the new one dropped. I had heard so much excitement and fervor over it. And I was not disappointed. The first season wove an intricate tale or warring partners, their complicated lives, and a killer boosted by religious idolatry. I became easily obsessed with the phenomenal acting, exquisite cinematography, and fantastic soundtrack. So once I finished it, I began anxiously awaiting the next season. I was pleased with the casting and expecting to be blown out of the water. Oh boy, I was pretty disappointed. In my opinion, the differences in the seasons come down to three key elements: cast, plot, and cinematography.

tds2The first season had an unbelievably strong cast. Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson are not only incredibly talented actors, the characters were created to have a brilliant give and take. While I also find Vince Vaughn, Colin Farrell, Taylor Kitsch, and Rachel McAdams talented, the characters lacked the same dynamic. To me, Taylor Kitsch’s character is extremely superfluous. His arc brings in elements that go unexplored. That whole money from the Middle East plot? Homosexual urges but also knocking up his girlfriend? Why? What was the point? The dynamic between Farrell and McAdams would and could have been explored without Kitsch’s middle man, third wheel part. Admittedly, Vaughn and Farrell have their own dynamic too, and it works well. Not as well as McConaughey and Harrelson in my opinion, but still good.

As previously mentioned, I found the plot of Kitsch’s character completely unnecessary. I would even go so far as to say it added nothing to the story. The only moment I really enjoyed his character was during the alley shoot out when the veteran army guy kept his cool while killing people, meanwhile McAdams and Farrell look prepared to vomit from not only shooting at people but killing them. The other point is the overall messiness of the plot. It had so many loose ends. The crow mask. The Middle Eastern money. Maybe it was the clever mythology background of the first season, but the story for the second season fell flat. I appreciated the conspiracy of it, but I don’t particularly like considering that cops are corrupt. It gives me the heebee jeebees.

Lastly, the cinematography paled in comparison. Cary Fukunaga was the brains behind the beauty of season one. That whole long shot sequence…Oh. My. God. That shot is unprecedentedly gorgeous. Rewatch it here.24-true-detective_1 

The backgrounds also differed. First season backwater Louisiana bayous complemented the grime and dirtiness of the story. In comparison, sunny California was an interesting juxtaposition. I think it could have been more of an accent if it had been done differently. The choice of an industrialized to death area was interesting, but to me Fukunaga’s lack of involvement was obvious and devastating. While the season still carried a gritty, cheap whiskey, and burning cigarette feel throughout the season, the intensity doesn’t compare in my mind to that of season one. Though T Bone Burnett keeps it going well with the soundtrack. If Fukunaga had still been helming production, the season would have been what it should have been.

Do you think season two lived up to the hype? Will you watch season three if/when it airs? We’re dying to know what you think after you’ve been able to stew on it a while. Comment below. 

  • Liz Marin

    Season one was fabulous. Couldnt wait each week to see it. Season two was disjointed, difficult to follow and boring. The only reason we watched it was to see if it would eventually get better. It didnt. If it does come back for a third season, we will watch it again but if it stats to resemble season 2, we are over it. Too many other shows to choose from!

  • Nahojism

    While I enjoyed season two I didn’t have the same expectations everyone else seem to have had. I knew it was very unlikely for the sophomore season to be as good as the first one was. You just don’t come across TV that great so often, not even on HBO. So in the end I wasn’t disappointed, it was pretty much on par with what I expected.

  • Morgana Marr

    The first season was excellent, one of the best police series I saw in my life; but the second was a big disappointment, too many characters, stories without closing, poor performances, shallowness, I hope that if there is a third, is better than this

  • Eleonora Iafano

    My husband enjoyed the first season immensely. I did too – and I will defend liking the second one. Everyone is entitled to the opinion and feelings on both seasons. I personally liked having four characters to learn about, to see their deepest fears, secret desires and to see just how bad chaos would follow them all. I really hope that there will be a season three next year!

  • Sajawal

    I was also very excited about s2 but
    I felt disappointed after watching it though the cast was expectionaly good but the whole plot seemed as distort and wasn’t able to intact viewers interust, compared to s1 which was pleasure to watch it Kept the viewers interust going n going suspense and thrill was immense one couldn’t simply switch a single scene of it.

  • Deanna

    I love both Season. I thought season 1 was a little weird. cant wait for the next one :)

  • Connie Sue Payne

    You summed it up perfectly. Season one was a masterpiece and season two just somehow didn’t cut it. I’ll start season three; but it needs to catch me immediately or I’m gone.

  • Christian Black

    I can watch a third season, provided that the direction is better. I think the Season 2 people tried too hard to recapture the weirdness that made the show so cool in the beginning.

Find an HBO Series

More HBO

Subscribe to HBO
Countries HBO Is In
Watch Game of Thrones Online
Watch The Leftovers Online
Watch Silicon Valley Online
HBO Premiere & Air Dates
True Detective Streaming
Other Streaming Television
HBO Boxing Live Stream
Game of Thrones on DVD & Blu-Ray
Watch Cinemax Online