What if Eddard Stark had taken The Black?

By Matt Weese on Apr 5, 2012 to Game of Thrones

Today we hear from Joe Hoskins, a Game of Thrones fan who takes a look at the hypothetical situation of Eddard (Ned) Stark joining the black brothers at The Wall instead of his ultimate end. Feel free to comment with your own thoughts below!

Call me crazy, but I like to think most readers and viewers were rooting for good old Ned Stark to line things out in King’s Landing and save the day. This would not have been quite as powerful or engaging as how it all turned out, but you know you wanted it to happen. So, in that regard, let’s get all hypothetical and consider what may have happened if Eddard Stark did not meet his demise at the command of Joffrey Lannister.

Imagine for a moment if Cersei, Varys or Littlefinger managed to counter and remedy Joffrey’s little vain and defiant decree at the end of the first book/season one. Ned Stark would then have been ordered to live out his days on the Wall, defending the realm with the Sworn Brothers of the Night’s Watch. This would have eliminated much of the content from the second and third book. Perhaps you would like to know what I mean. Well, then read on, my friend.

Robb may or may not have continued his campaign depending on whether or not Sansa and Arya were released along with Ned. However, if they released Arya, but decided to keep Sansa as Joffrey’s betrothed, Robb probably wouldn’t have surrendered his King in the North crown. The content I was referring to that would be eradicated is that of the matters a little farther north.

Basically, I imagine Ned would have defeated the wildings, the Others and whatever else was foolish enough to cross his path. The trouble at the Fist of the First Men would just have been a little scuffle for the great Eddard Stark. Furthermore, if the Night’s Watch was able to continue their ranging from there, they would have been able to roll up on Mance Rayder and his posse. I’m confident Ned would have shown them the finer points of Valyrian steel whilst he swung Ice with devastating precision. The wildlings would have fallen like the grass before my weedeater.

I know Ice is reserved for another matter, but since we’re being hypothetical, he might as well have it. He would be taking down mammoths and giants like nobody’s business with Ice. The same goes for the Others. Ice may not be Dragonglass, but with Ned behind the hilt, it wouldn’t really matter.

So with the whole invasion of wildings/Others solved, the Old Bear would probably insist Ned take over as Lord Commander of the Night’s Watch. With no reason left to defend the Wall, Ned could lead the Night’s Watch down to join Robb and all his bannermen. Then they could mount an assault on King’s Landing to unseat the Lannisters. Ned Stark wins!

As you can see, while this might have been wildly entertaining to see Ned flex his heroicness, it would have made the series incredibly shorter and nobody would have wanted that. But still…

  • Mike T

    actually the name is Joffrey Baratheon

  • spacechampion

    Ice is not dragonglass, true, but it is dragonsteel ie. Valyrian Steel. Which is arguably better than dragonglass.

  • Hans

    I see one argument against this, and that is the fate of Yoren and the rest of the crew heading North to the wall. Ned would have been with them, and most likely have shared that fate. Plus, Ned being a man of “honor” (aka thick headed), he probably would have headed straight to the wall even if he did escape the kings army.

    Ned’s death is the equivalent to the assassination of archduke Franz Ferdinand. The entire story would be different had that not occurred. Interesting alternative take on it- I like the idea of the “What-If” scenario.

    One I often consider is what if Bran hadn’t been caught?

  • oracle86

    The one thing that would have come of it – Jon would have had a chance to find out his true parentage. Pity it was not to be. :(

  • oracle86

    The men of the Night’s Watch do not interfere with political matters. Their ONLY purpose is to defend the Wall. If Ned Stark had taken the black, he would not command the Night’s Watch to fight Lannisters. After all, he is a man of his word.

    • Yeah, yeah… SPOILER.. but have you read the later books? :) *evil grin*

Find an HBO Series

More HBO

Subscribe to HBO
Countries HBO Is In
Watch Game of Thrones Online
Watch The Leftovers Online
Watch Silicon Valley Online
HBO Premiere & Air Dates
True Detective Streaming
Other Streaming Television
HBO Boxing Live Stream
Game of Thrones on DVD & Blu-Ray
Watch Cinemax Online