HBO Fall Documentary: TALES FROM THE ORGAN TRADE

By Jef Dinsmore on Nov 5, 2013 to Documentaries

Doc-logo

Overview: Filmed over the course of three years in eight countries on three continents, TALES FROM THE ORGAN TRADE reveals a world where “villains” often save lives and the medical establishment, bound by its own rules and bureaucracy, too often watches people die. From a village in the Philippines, where more than 300 men have sold a kidney for the price of a laptop,docs_talesorganteade to an unemployed American who answers a Craigslist ad to donate his kidney for a $20,000 payoff, the film pulls back the curtain on this lucrative illegal business. This documentary exposes the shadowy black-market world of organ trafficking, from the street-level brokers who solicit organs and the rogue surgeons who perform the transplants, to the impoverished donors willing to sacrifice a part of their bodies for a quick payday and the desperate patients who face the agonizing choice of obeying the law or saving their lives.  It is directed by Emmy winning filmmaker and investigative journalist Ric Esther Bienstock and filmmaker David Cronenberg narrates.

Expectations: I have been waiting for this documentary to come along. It was originally on the schedule in 2012, actually at this time of year, and it got bumped and never aired then. Well, it is back and I am most eager to see it.

 At first I wasn’t sure exactly what this was about. When it first came to my attention I thought it was more about the cases of organ trafficking in which unwilling victims are kidnapped, and an organ harvested in a totally unsanitary locale after being chilled in an ice cube filled bathtub or some other horrible scenario. However, since reading the overview I was given from HBO PR and seeing the trailer I have learned that that is not what plays out here. Instead we will hear stories about willing donors selling their body parts out of desperation. It may not be as awful as the person robbed of a kidney but it still a nasty business.

 It is a nasty business I care to examine. My mind fills with questions of what drives the decisions; how legal and capable are the medical staff involved; how well do the impoverished survive surgery, healing and being minus a kidney; do any of them actually improve their status after being paid off; what is being done to stop the vicious cycle and on and on.

 I guess I expect this documentary to pretty much be the definitive report on the Organ Trade. I’ ll see if all my questions get answered.  

 

Gut Reaction: Oh, yes they did each and every one. In 83 minutes this film covered every angle. I guess people don’t need to kidnap people to get a big payoff because there is obviously willing and desperate donors everywhere. I like how TALES OF THE ORGAN TRADE is structured. It quickly sets up the scenario and then, with the assist of some graphics play, plots out the trail we must follow to understand how the life changing process plays out. We go from a recipient’s quest and learn of the doctor, the fixer, the broker and to the donor (at least in one case). It was interesting to find most of the donors with no regrets; doctors and fixers being steadfast in believing they did no wrong and recipients fighting for their lives. Then it throws in the moral and ethical issues. Think about it – donors sign consents willingly, yet they are trained in what to say and do. They get paid, but they can’t say they are doing it for monetary reasons and those in need of an organ are just doing what they need to survive.

Dr. Sonmez - the "villan"

Dr. Sonmez – the “villain”

 All this makes a fascinating story perfectly narrated by Mr. Cronenberg. It offers an investigation, a medical story and personal stories. It is controversial, emotional, scary and unjust but more so is truly a story of desperation. The feeling of desperation is one of the strongest emotions you can play out in my opinion and this one does it well.       

 In Conclusion: TALES OF THE ORGAN TRADE delivered what I had hoped for and answered the questions I had asked. It is the definitive report on the organ trafficking business. It couldn’t have been explained better. Feel free to disagree in the comments below.

 Other HBO air dates are 11.07 at noon; 11.10 at 12:30pm, 11.13 at 8:30am; 11.16 at 2:00pm and 11.24 at 5:00 am. It can also be found on HBO2 and HBOGo.

  • MR

    First, the documentary doesn’t talk
    about unwilling victims who were kidnaped on Kosovo during the war
    and whose organs were used in Medicus clinic. More about that can be
    found in Dick Marty (human rights investigator) report (http://assembly.coe.int/asp/apfeaturesmanager/defaultartsiteview.asp?ID=964). Carla Del
    Ponte, former chief prosecutor for the International Criminal
    Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, also claims that people were
    kidnapped on Kosovo for illegal organ trafficking. I realy can’t
    understand how is it possible that this isn’t mentioned in the
    documentary. And the documentary is giving human face to Jusuf
    Sonmez and for me it’s like making Hitler looks human. There are
    serious accusations that connect Sonmez with kidnaping people, doing
    inhuman operations on captives, taking their organs and selling them
    on black market. Secondly, yes, I agree, I would do anything to save
    people I love, but it doesn’t mean it is right. What bothers me is
    that this documentary is trying to justify organ trafficking. Things
    are black and white – organ trafficking can’t be justified by any
    means. It seems that we got so accustomed to the fact that world is
    unfair – poor suffer, rich get what they want, that we’ve stopped
    asking the right questions how to change that.

  • ResearchPaperWriter

    Where can I watch the full documentary?

  • OneVeryGratefulPerson

    Saw the documentary last night. So powerful. I spent 3 miserable years on Dialysis after contracting a strain of the e-coli virus. I am one of the fortunate ones as I received a cadaver kidney. The producers did a wonderful job of presenting a complex, emotional, societal issue with utmost balance. It raised many questions in my mind as to what is ethical and what’s not. I’ll be questioning the issues raised for a long time. I hope everyone watches this documentary. It was quite difficult for me to watch at times but I couldn’t pull my self away.

  • Nora Saunders

    A friend of mine from Atlanta was found dead in a California Valley in the desert and all of his organs were missing. This just happened! He left from Atlanta in July and apparently the friends he made that he was traveling with set him up. They just found his body missing all of his organs.The police say it was animals. The family knows different.

  • Keith

    How and where can we buy a copy of this film?

    • It’s still out in some special theaters and just appeared on HBO. I’d guess you could get it at the HBO Store in a few months! Answer: Not out yet.

      It is on HBOGo though if you want to share with people or watch any time.










Find an HBO Series





More HBO

Subscribe to HBO
Countries HBO Is In
Watch Game of Thrones Online
Watch The Leftovers Online
Watch Silicon Valley Online
HBO Premiere & Air Dates
True Detective Streaming
Other Streaming Television
HBO Boxing Live Stream
Game of Thrones on DVD & Blu-Ray
Watch Cinemax Online